CM Punk vs. MJF (AEW 3/6/22)

Ultimately, it’s fine that they never closed this one up properly.

MJF traps a bloody CM Punk in a sleeper hold.

This was a commission from Patreon. If you’d like me to review a wrestling match or film of your choosing, you can make it so by subscribing to my Patreon for $5/mo, or by buying an individual review over at Ko-fi for $10!

It has been so long since CM Punk left AEW that I’ve forgotten the parts of his run there that I largely did not like. Punk put on a lot of belters in AEW, but two of his feuds in particular stood out for feeling hollow to me at the time, and would, were I to revisit them again in full, probably fare worse now for the amount of time that’s passed/how much my tolerance for his particular brand of wrestling snakeoil has changed since he started selling it elsewhere. I’ll probably have to revisit his feud against “Hangman” Adam Page someday, but if you ever wondered why I had relatively little to say about Punk’s feud with MJF while I was helming a wrestling website, it’s kinda simple: I mostly figured that nobody wanted a naysayer in the room at the time.

Don’t get me wrong: I thought that the matches were great, and I have particularly fond memories of Punk running Bret/Diesel with Wardlow, but I’ve never been a fan of MJF as a character and had, by the time he was cutting promos about his childhood hero spurning him at an autograph signing, really grown tired of his having Personal History or Poorly Regulated Emotions About His Past. I know the stuff Max was dredging up during the Punk feud was particularly heavy, but the truth is that neither he nor Punk had the acting chops to make any of it particularly resonant to me. Both wrestlers work so hard to ride the line between working and shooting in their promos that there was nothing for me to latch onto, unlike when Page would let a winking reference to workers rights fly or Eddie Kingston leaned into his professional experience of Punk or when Jon Moxley famously sized him up. When Punk asked MJF whether his story about antisemitism was real, the answer was yes and no to the extent that it neither mattered nor stood to differentiate Punk’s being a bad hero from other perceived slights visited upon MJF from the likes of Cody Rhodes, Chris Jericho, and William Regal. 

Luckily, it is 2026, and CM Punk’s time in AEW may as well have been a mirage. The good stuff was and probably is still good, the bad stuff doesn’t matter, and both parties — Punk, who has finally realized his dream of “mattering” in WWE, and AEW, who have recovered from the damage wrought by the end of Punk’s time with the company — are much better off with all of this shit in the increasingly distant past. Whether or not I’m able to see past all of that in watching an AEW CM Punk match for the first time since All In 2023, I don’t know. I was pretty burnt up about it, and pretty burnt out on wrestling, and probably wouldn’t revisit this were it not for the fact that I was asked to with the promise of money attached. What I can definitely say is that neither MJF’s fakeout entrance or Punk’s “Time to go back to the old me” entrance to “Miseria Cantare” matter one bit, good on Jim Ross for talking over that nostalgiabaiting slop.

The match itself is a tale of two halves, the first being better than the second. In the first, Punk’s veteran guile and the fact that he’s been there before gives you everything you want out of the premise, ostensibly trapping MJF, the coward, forcing him to take his just deserts. They are much less cute about what they can and can’t do with ten feet of chain connecting them at the neck, the bits of close fighting, particularly Max getting gritty and mean and tugging at Punk’s collar to yank him out of a move or down to the canvas being particularly good, certainly much better than them trying to negotiate the chain into one of their respective signature spots. Punk starts bleeding first and it’s an iconic blade job, just fucking gnarly, spilling out onto his face, Max’s back, the canvas, and so on.

CM Punk chokes MJF with a dog collar.

Despite the visual, I still think that opening half falls somewhat short of classic dog collar work — not just Punk’s, but the Piper/Valentine match that gets cited in the lead in to here. It’s been a while since I’ve seen the Brodie Lee vs. Cody Rhodes dog collar match from Dynamite, but I think that’s what this one more closely follows than, say, a peak Mad Dog Connelly dog collar encounter, eventually eschewing the visceral thrill of a straight up brawl to instead work a match, the ol’ canard of “I went to a fight and a hockey game broke out” as applied to a pro wrestling match.It works, but not as well as when Punk and Max are working to raise welts on each others’ backs. 

Part of me wonders if I’m just not able to put any critical distance between my feelings about Punk and this match’s attempt at delivering a sense of justice so far as how he’s been manipulated and wronged by Max is concerned. Before I get there, I’ll go ahead and say that my feelings about MJF from the time and in watching it back are essentially unchanged: he’s capable of good work, but mostly stinks. He’s a heel, but in a wink-wink, nudge-nudge kinda way, and while we’re not quite at the point of his career where fans are chanting “he’s our scumbag,” there’s never been a moment of MJF’s AEW career where it felt like there was anything truly bitter or mean-spirited about him. He’s a simulacrum of heel wrestler impulses, someone who has studied the greats and “the greats” and ground their shtick into a sausage he’s able to sell as his own, but it feels cartoonish, which is not helped by how far into overdrive his villany is pushed by commentary, nor by MJF’s willingness to lean into cartoon shtick. The match has the look of a trip through the fucking grindhouse and the soul of a mid-range John Cena main event, and that isn’t helped when Max grabs a mic to cut a mid-match promo Punk, only for Punk to brush him off like he was Big Match John in an I Quit match. Neither of them being actors of John Cena’s caliber, it’s probably for the best that the microphone only comes into play here. 

From there, the match kind of meanders. Having given us the money shot of Punk gushing blood everywhere, they have a hall pass to do whatever they want: comedy bits, Bret Hart tributes, slow builds to big spots that would be better served in another kind of match. I like Punk’s focus on MJF’s hand, and like most of the moves Max makes to show you how that work pays off for Punk, but you can see him working that out in his head a little in a sequence that requires him to block the GTS, just a little hitch before he counters it like someone who hadn’t hurt their hand might, which would feel nitpicky were it not for it being part of a trio of spots — an earlier cute chain exchange in the corner and a later one where he gets lost trying to get out of the ring without getting hung by the chain en route to an apron tombstone spot — that are a confirmation that, so far as this sort of thing goes, the old ways remain the best. 

The finish isn’t great, either. They dick around way too much with the thumbtacks, hitting half a dozen “will he fall into them or not” spots and another half dozen significant looks to where the thumbtacks are spots for Punk to eventually mostly miss them on the superplex, and 30 minutes into their psychosexual traumedy is a little late for Max to do more hee haw comedy bits about how much they hurt when he crawls across the thumbtacks to pin Punk. Wardlow coming to the ring to turn on Max being the point of this one would have been better if a) Wardlow’s push as a newly-minted face wasn’t fated to end via injury, and b) if Punk and MJF had a third match in them, but Wardlow got injured and AEW “won” the bidding war of 2024 so we’re left with something that let Max off the hook, brought no closure to Punk, and did not elevate Wardlow. I can’t hold that against the match except to say that it’s the second part of an incomplete trilogy, and that I’m more than okay with having never gotten the third part. I’m probably relatively alone there, but I’ve got to live my truth.

Rating: *** & ¾ 


Torture Rack and Honey is free for anyone to read, but if you’d like to chip in, you can become a Patreon supporter or donate to my Ko-fi, where you can commission a match review for $5. Thanks for reading! For even more, check out BIG EGG and The Patron Saints of Sick Sons of Bitches.